Club History
A Brief and Disputed History of the Fauntleroy Creek Casting Club
The Fauntleroy Creek Casting Club was founded sometime between 1968 and 1973.
This is one of the few details on which the available records agree, although calling it agreement may be generous.
The most commonly accepted account begins with four fishermen leaving West Seattle for a steelhead trip to the Olympic Peninsula. The river is never identified in the surviving records. Later members have attempted to determine it from weather reports, ferry schedules, old fishing regulations, and the increasingly unreliable memories of those said to have been present.
No useful conclusion has been reached.
Three of the four men are generally agreed upon. The fourth depends largely on who is telling the story. Several names appear in club records, sometimes within the same decade. There has been periodic discussion of resolving the discrepancy.
There has been less interest in actually doing so.
What is known is that the fishing was poor.
Some versions describe the fish as “gray ghosts.” Others report no fish at all. One ledger entry simply reads:
Fishing attempted. Results inconclusive.
At some point during the return trip, there was a flat tire.
This is where the accounts become considerably more detailed and considerably less consistent.
Depending on the version, the tire was punctured on a logging road, beside the highway, near a ferry terminal, or while the vehicle was parked. One account places the incident before the fishing trip. Another insists there were two flat tires.
Every surviving version agrees on one fact:
It was Randall’s fault.
Exactly what Randall did has never been established.
While dealing with the tire, the four fishermen apparently began discussing the need for a proper fishing club. The reasons given vary. Some accounts suggest it was intended to organize future trips. Others describe a desire to establish standards of conduct, preserve useful fishing information, settle arguments, or prevent Randall from making transportation decisions.
By the time they returned to West Seattle, some form of agreement had apparently been reached.
The name Fauntleroy Creek Casting Club appears in writing shortly afterward, although no founding document has ever been located. The earliest known club ledger begins without explanation, as though the organization had already existed long enough that an introduction was unnecessary.
It contains fishing reports, tide notes, incomplete meeting minutes, several unexplained names, and expenses that nobody has been able to reconcile.
There is no record of a permanent clubhouse.
Meetings appear to have occurred wherever members were already gathered: homes, garages, taverns, beaches, ferry lines, parking lots, fly shops, and occasionally near actual fishing water.
There are also repeated references to an initiation conducted at midnight during a low tide.
The purpose of the ceremony is unclear.
Whether it continues today is also unclear.
Some members insist it ended decades ago. Others maintain that it never stopped. No current member has admitted to organizing one, and no reliable account exists describing exactly what takes place.
This is generally considered sufficient evidence that the tradition remains active.
Over the years, pieces of early club equipment have reportedly passed from member to member. Rods, reels, flies, notebooks, patches, and other objects of uncertain importance occasionally surface. Provenance is rarely complete.
The original ledger has proven similarly difficult to account for.
It has been reported in garages, tackle rooms, basements, cabins, and once in the possession of someone who claimed not to be a member.
At present, its location is officially unknown.
Finding
The Casting Club continues regardless.
The exact year of its founding remains disputed.
The identity of one founder remains disputed.
The location of the original steelhead trip remains disputed.
The cause of the flat tire does not.
It was Randall’s fault.
